| Player | Country | Position | born | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||
| Charles Alcock |
|
England | Forward | 02/12/1842 |
| B | ||||
| Morton Betts |
|
England | Defender | 30/08/1847 |
| Francis Birley |
|
England | Defender | 14/03/1850 |
| Alexander Bonsor |
|
England | Forward | 07/10/1851 |
| E | ||||
| John Edwards |
|
Wales | Forward | 21/03/1850 |
| G | ||||
| Fred Green |
|
England | Defender | 21/06/1851 |
| H | ||||
| Frank Heron |
|
England | Forward | 10/09/1853 |
| George Heron |
|
England | Forward | 30/01/1852 |
| Leonard Howell |
|
England | Defender | 06/08/1848 |
| Thomas Hughes |
|
England | Midfielder | 17/09/1851 |
| K | ||||
| William Kenyon-Slaney |
|
England | Forward | 24/08/1847 |
| Robert Kingsford |
|
England | Forward | 23/12/1849 |
| Arthur Kinnaird |
|
Scotland | Midfielder | 16/02/1847 |
| L | ||||
| William Lindsay |
|
England | Defender | 03/08/1847 |
| S | ||||
| Alfred Stratford |
|
England | Defender | 05/09/1853 |
| W | ||||
| Henry Wace |
|
England | Forward | 21/09/1853 |
| Reginald Welch |
|
England | Defender | 20/06/1851 |
| Charles Wollaston |
|
England | Forward | 31/07/1849 |
| John Wylie |
|
England | Forward | 1853 |
