Major League Soccer   M. W D L goals
  at home 40 22 6 12 64 : 44
  Away 45 13 7 25 57 : 70
  Neutral Place 2 0 0 2 1 : 5
  87 35 13 39 122 : 119
overall   M. W D L goals
  at home 40 22 6 12 64 : 44
  Away 45 13 7 25 57 : 70
  Neutral Place 2 0 0 2 1 : 5
  87 35 13 39 122 : 119
Major League Soccer
2024 2. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 3:0 (1:0)
2023 6. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:1 (1:1)
2023 2. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:1 (0:1)
2022 9. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:1 (0:0)
2022 2. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:1 (0:0)
2021 7. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:2 (1:1)
2021 6. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:1 (0:1)
2021 5. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:0 (1:0)
2020 Playoffs 1. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 3:2 (1:1)
2020 MLS is Back Tournament Group E Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:0 (1:0)
2019 5. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:3 (1:1)
2019 1. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:1 (1:1)
2018 Playoffs Quarter-finals New York RB - Columbus Crew 3:0 (1:0)
2018 Playoffs Quarter-finals Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:0 (0:0)
2018 5. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:3 (0:3)
2018 4. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:1 (1:0)
2017 7. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 3:2 (1:1)
2017 2. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:0 (2:0)
2016 8. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 3:2 (0:0)
2016 4. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:1 (0:0)
2015 Playoffs Semi-finals New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:0 (0:0)
2015 Playoffs Semi-finals Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:0 (1:0)
2015 8. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:1 (2:1)
2015 5. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:1 (1:1)
2015 1. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:2 (0:0)
2014 8. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:3 (0:2)
2014 5. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 4:1 (2:1)
2014 2. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:1 (1:0)
2013 6. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:0 (0:0)
2013 3. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:2 (1:1)
2013 3. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 0:1 (0:0)
2012 7. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 3:1 (1:1)
2012 2. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:4 (0:3)
2011 4. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:1 (1:0)
2011 1. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 0:0 (0:0)
2010 5. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 2:0 (1:0)
2010 3. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:3 (0:2)
2009 6. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:0 (0:0)
2009 4. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:0 (1:0)
2008 Playoffs Final Columbus Crew - New York RB 3:1 (1:0)
2008 8. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 3:1 (0:0)
2008 7. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 3:1 (1:1)
2008 2. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 2:0 (2:0)
2007 4. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:0 (0:0)
2007 2. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 4:0 (1:0)
2007 1. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 0:0 (0:0)
2006 6. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 1:0 (0:0)
2006 5. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 1:0 (0:0)
2006 4. Round Columbus Crew - New York RB 0:2 (0:0)
2006 3. Round New York RB - Columbus Crew 0:0 (0:0)
2005 5. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 2:1 (0:1)
2005 4. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 1:0 (0:0)
2005 3. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 3:2 (2:1)
2005 2. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 0:3 (0:1)
2004 7. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:1 (0:1)
2004 6. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 4:2 (1:1)
2004 5. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:1 (1:1)
2004 1. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 1:3 (1:1)
2003 6. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:0 (0:0, 0:0) aet
2003 3. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 1:1 (1:0, 1:1) aet
2003 1. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 0:1 (0:0)
2003 1. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:1 (0:0)
2002 5. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 2:3 (1:2)
2002 5. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:3 (1:1)
2002 2. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 1:2 (0:0, 1:1) aet
2002 1. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:1 (0:1)
2001 5. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:1 (0:1)
2001 4. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:1 (0:0)
2000 3. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 0:2 (0:0)
2000 2. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:1 (0:0)
1999 7. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 1:2 (1:1)
1999 6. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 2:4 (1:1)
1999 4. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:1 (1:0)
1999 1. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:0 (0:0)
1998 Playoffs Quarter-finals MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:2 n.P.
1998 Playoffs Quarter-finals Columbus Crew - MetroStars 5:3 (4:0)
1998 7. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 4:3 (3:1)
1998 6. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 3:1 (0:0)
1998 5. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 3:0 (2:0)
1998 4. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:1 (1:1)
1997 6. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:1 (0:0)
1997 3. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:1 (0:0)
1997 2. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 3:0 (1:0)
1997 1. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 2:1 (2:1)
1996 6. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 1:0 (1:0)
1996 6. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 2:0 (2:0)
1996 3. Round Columbus Crew - MetroStars 0:4 (0:1)
1996 1. Round MetroStars - Columbus Crew 0:2 (0:1)

For games that were decided on penalties the score after 120 minutes will be included in the ranking