FA Cup   M. W D L goals
  at home 3 1 1 1 2 : 1
  Away 1 0 0 1 3 : 4
  4 1 1 2 5 : 5
National League   M. W D L goals
  at home 8 4 2 2 17 : 9
  Away 8 2 4 2 12 : 11
  16 6 6 4 29 : 20
National League North   M. W D L goals
  at home 1 0 0 1 0 : 1
  Away 2 1 0 1 3 : 4
  3 1 0 2 3 : 5
overall   M. W D L goals
  at home 12 5 3 4 19 : 11
  Away 11 3 4 4 18 : 19
  Neutral Place 0 0 0 0 0 : 0
  23 8 7 8 37 : 30
FA Cup
2019/2020 1. Round York City - Altrincham FC 0:1 (0:0)
1985/1986 4. Round York City - Altrincham FC 2:0
1981/1982 2. Round Altrincham FC - York City 4:3
1981/1982 2. Round York City - Altrincham FC 0:0
National League
2023/2024 39. Round Altrincham FC - York City 6:1 (3:0)
2023/2024 3. Round York City - Altrincham FC 2:2 (2:1)
2022/2023 32. Round York City - Altrincham FC 1:2 (0:1)
2022/2023 19. Round Altrincham FC - York City 2:1 (0:1)
2010/2011 26. Round Altrincham FC - York City 0:0 (0:0)
2010/2011 5. Round York City - Altrincham FC 3:0 (0:0)
2009/2010 43. Round York City - Altrincham FC 2:1
2009/2010 27. Round Altrincham FC - York City 0:0
2008/2009 31. Round Altrincham FC - York City 1:1
2008/2009 26. Round York City - Altrincham FC 1:2
2007/2008 27. Round Altrincham FC - York City 2:2
2007/2008 7. Round York City - Altrincham FC 2:2
2006/2007 31. Round Altrincham FC - York City 0:4
2006/2007 18. Round York City - Altrincham FC 1:0
2005/2006 33. Round Altrincham FC - York City 0:3
2005/2006 8. Round York City - Altrincham FC 5:0
National League North
2019/2020 1. Round Altrincham FC - York City 1:3
2018/2019 8. Round York City - Altrincham FC 0:1
2018/2019 4. Round Altrincham FC - York City 3:0

For games that were decided on penalties the score after 120 minutes will be included in the ranking