1. Round 04/08/2023 Coleraine FC - Ballymena United 2:1 yellow card
2. Round 11/08/2023 Ballymena United - Crusaders FC 1:2
3. Round 15/08/2023 Larne FC - Ballymena United 3:0 yellow card
4. Round 18/08/2023 Ballymena United - Linfield FC 0:1 yellow card
5. Round 25/08/2023 Ballymena United - Glentoran FC 0:2
6. Round 02/09/2023 Glenavon FC - Ballymena United 1:0 yellow-red card
8. Round 16/09/2023 Ballymena United - Loughgall FC 1:3
9. Round 23/09/2023 Ballymena United - Cliftonville FC 0:2
11. Round 07/10/2023 Ballymena United - Newry City FC 0:2
12. Round 13/10/2023 Crusaders FC - Ballymena United 1:0
13. Round 21/10/2023 Ballymena United - Coleraine FC 3:1 yellow card
14. Round 28/10/2023 Ballymena United - Dungannon Swifts 1:1
15. Round 04/11/2023 Loughgall FC - Ballymena United 5:2
16. Round 11/11/2023 Ballymena United - Glenavon FC 0:1
17. Round 18/11/2023 Glentoran FC - Ballymena United 5:0
18. Round 25/11/2023 Linfield FC - Ballymena United 4:0
19. Round 02/12/2023 Ballymena United - Larne FC 0:0 yellow card
21. Round 15/12/2023 Ballymena United - Carrick Rangers 0:2
22. Round 23/12/2023 Cliftonville FC - Ballymena United 2:0
23. Round 26/12/2023 Ballymena United - Coleraine FC 3:1
24. Round 30/12/2023 Glenavon FC - Ballymena United 0:1
25. Round 13/01/2024 Ballymena United - Dungannon Swifts 2:4 Goal
26. Round 20/01/2024 Cliftonville FC - Ballymena United 3:0
27. Round 27/01/2024 Ballymena United - Loughgall FC 0:1
28. Round 09/02/2024 Newry City FC - Ballymena United 1:1
29. Round 17/02/2024 Ballymena United - Larne FC 0:1
30. Round 24/02/2024 Linfield FC - Ballymena United 2:0
31. Round 09/03/2024 Ballymena United - Crusaders FC 2:4
32. Round 16/03/2024 Ballymena United - Carrick Rangers 0:2
33. Round 23/03/2024 Glentoran FC - Ballymena United 4:0 red card