| Player | Country | Position | born | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B | ||||
| Thomas Bryan |
|
Wales | Forward | 1866 |
| D | ||||
| John Davies |
|
Wales | Forward | 1862 |
| William Davies |
|
Wales | Forward | 1855 |
| F | ||||
| George Farmer |
|
Wales | Forward | 1863 |
| G | ||||
| Richard Gough |
|
Wales | Goalkeeper | 1860 |
| H | ||||
| George Higham |
|
Wales | Defender | 1855 |
| O | ||||
| Thomas Owen |
|
Wales | Defender | 1861 |
| William Owen |
|
Wales | Forward | 1857 |
| P | ||||
| Seth Powell |
|
Wales | Defender | 1862 |
| R | ||||
| John Roach |
|
Wales | Forward | 1862 |
| S | ||||
| George Savin |
|
Wales | Midfielder | 1860 |
| Edward Shaw |
|
Wales | Forward | 1864 |
| Watkin Shone |
|
Wales | Midfielder | 1857 |
| V | ||||
| John Vaughan |
|
Wales | Forward | 1856 |
| W | ||||
| Joseph Williams |
|
Wales | Midfielder | 13/09/1857 |
England