1. Round 10/03/2019 Birmingham Legion - Bethlehem Steel FC 0:2
1. Round 16/03/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - North Carolina FC 0:1
1. Round 24/03/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Memphis 901 0:1
1. Round 30/03/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Pittsburgh Riverhounds 2:2
2. Round 06/04/2019 Swope Park Rangers - Bethlehem Steel FC 3:4 Goal
2. Round 14/04/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Charleston Battery 3:1 yellow card
2. Round 17/04/2019 Charlotte Independence - Bethlehem Steel FC 2:1 yellow card
2. Round 20/04/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Indy Eleven 0:3 yellow card
3. Round 04/05/2019 Loudoun United - Bethlehem Steel FC 3:3
3. Round 12/05/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Atlanta United II 1:1
3. Round 19/05/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Ottawa Fury 0:3
3. Round 26/05/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Louisville City FC 2:2 yellow-red card
4. Round 09/06/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Nashville SC 1:4
4. Round 16/06/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Saint Louis FC 3:1
4. Round 22/06/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Tampa Bay Rowdies 1:2
4. Round 29/06/2019 Hartford Athletic - Bethlehem Steel FC 0:3
5. Round 21/07/2019 Louisville City FC - Bethlehem Steel FC 0:1
5. Round 28/07/2019 Saint Louis FC - Bethlehem Steel FC 3:0
6. Round 01/08/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Hartford Athletic 0:3 yellow-red card
7. Round 01/09/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Swope Park Rangers 2:0
7. Round 08/09/2019 North Carolina FC - Bethlehem Steel FC 3:3
7. Round 15/09/2019 Indy Eleven - Bethlehem Steel FC 2:1 Goal yellow card
7. Round 19/09/2019 Bethlehem Steel FC - Loudoun United 5:2
7. Round 22/09/2019 Tampa Bay Rowdies - Bethlehem Steel FC 6:1
7. Round 29/09/2019 Memphis 901 - Bethlehem Steel FC 5:0 yellow card
8. Round 10/10/2019 Atlanta United II - Bethlehem Steel FC 5:2 yellow card
8. Round 19/10/2019 Charleston Battery - Bethlehem Steel FC 5:1