| MLS | 19/06/06 | CD Chivas | - | Columbus Crew | 2:0 | ||||
| MLS | 25/06/06 | Columbus Crew | - | CD Chivas | 1:1 | ||||
| MLS | 13/05/07 | Columbus Crew | - | CD Chivas | 1:1 |  |
|||
| MLS | 11/05/08 | San Jose Earthquakes | - | Columbus Crew | 2:3 | ||||
| MLS | 08/06/08 | Columbus Crew | - | San Jose Earthquakes | 0:2 | ||||
| MLS | 28/05/09 | Columbus Crew | - | San Jose Earthquakes | 2:1 | ||||
| MLS | 09/08/09 | San Jose Earthquakes | - | Columbus Crew | 0:3 | ||||
| MLS | 03/06/10 | San Jose Earthquakes | - | Columbus Crew | 2:2 | ||||
| MLS | 03/10/10 | Columbus Crew | - | San Jose Earthquakes | 0:0 | ||||
| MLS | 15/05/11 | San Jose Earthquakes | - | Columbus Crew | 3:0 | |
|||
| MLS | 17/07/11 | Columbus Crew | - | San Jose Earthquakes | 0:0 | ||||
| MLS | 20/05/12 | San Jose Earthquakes | - | Columbus Crew | 1:1 | ||||
| MLS | 16/03/13 | Columbus Crew | - | San Jose Earthquakes | 1:1 | ||||
| MLS | 20/08/15 | Columbus Crew | - | New York City FC | 2:2 | ||||
| MLS | 29/08/15 | New York City FC | - | Columbus Crew | 1:2 | ||||
| MLS | 17/04/16 | Columbus Crew | - | New York City FC | 3:2 | |
|||
| MLS | 14/08/16 | Columbus Crew | - | New York City FC | 3:3 | ||||
| MLS | 23/10/16 | New York City FC | - | Columbus Crew | 4:1 | ||||
| MLS | 03/06/18 | Columbus Crew | - | Toronto FC | 3:3 | |
USA