| Open Cup | 20/06/19 | D.C. United | - | New York City FC | 1:2 | ||||
| MLS | 08/11/20 | Chicago Fire | - | New York City FC | 3:4 | ||||
| MLS | 22/05/22 | New York City FC | - | Chicago Fire | 1:0 | ||||
| MLS | 23/04/23 | New York City FC | - | FC Dallas | 3:1 | ||||
| MLS | 11/06/23 | Real Salt Lake | - | New York City FC | 0:0 |  |
|||
| MLS | 31/08/23 | New York City FC | - | CF Montréal | 2:0 | ||||
| MLS | 08/10/23 | D.C. United | - | New York City FC | 2:0 |
USA