| NASL | 03/07/16 | Puerto Rico FC | - | Indy Eleven | 1:1 |  |
|||
| NASL | 23/10/16 | Indy Eleven | - | Puerto Rico FC | 3:0 | ||||
| NASL | 01/04/17 | Indy Eleven | - | Puerto Rico FC | 3:3 | ||||
| NASL | 09/04/17 | Puerto Rico FC | - | Indy Eleven | 1:1 | ||||
| NASL | 05/10/17 | Indy Eleven | - | Puerto Rico FC | 2:1 | ||||
| NASL | 21/10/17 | Puerto Rico FC | - | Indy Eleven | 2:1 | ||||
| USL | 21/09/19 | Birmingham Legion | - | Indy Eleven | 1:0 |
USA