| New York American FC | Season 1960/1961 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1958/1959 | 1 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1955/1956 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1954/1955 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1953/1954 | 4 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1952/1953 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1951/1952 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1950/1951 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1949/1950 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1948/1949 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1947/1948 | 1 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1946/1947 | 1 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1945/1946 | 1 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1944/1945 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1943/1944 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1942/1943 | 4 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1941/1942 | 4 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1940/1941 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1939/1940 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1938/1939 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1937/1938 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1936/1937 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1935/1936 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1934/1935 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1933/1934 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1932/1933 | 5 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1931/1932 | 3 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1930/1931 | 1 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1923/1924 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1922/1923 | 2 Players/Coaches |
| New York American FC | Season 1921/1922 | 2 Players/Coaches |
USA