| 26. Round | 26/12/2023 | Hartlepool United | - | Oldham Athletic | 1:3 | ||||
| 27. Round | 30/12/2023 | Oldham Athletic | - | Hartlepool United | 2:0 | ||||
| 28. Round | 06/01/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Oxford City | 2:1 |  |
|||
| 23. Round | 09/01/2024 | AFC Fylde | - | Hartlepool United | 2:1 | |
|||
| 29. Round | 20/01/2024 | Ebbsfleet United | - | Hartlepool United | 0:1 | ||||
| 30. Round | 23/01/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Kidderminster Harriers | 0:1 | ||||
| 34. Round | 17/02/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Boreham Wood | 3:1 | ||||
| 35. Round | 20/02/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Altrincham FC | 3:2 | ||||
| 36. Round | 24/02/2024 | Solihull Moors | - | Hartlepool United | 2:1 | ||||
| 41. Round | 23/03/2024 | Eastleigh FC | - | Hartlepool United | 1:1 | ||||
| 42. Round | 29/03/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Halifax Town | 1:0 | ||||
| 43. Round | 01/04/2024 | Rochdale AFC | - | Hartlepool United | 1:1 | |
|||
| 44. Round | 06/04/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Aldershot Town | 2:0 | ||||
| 39. Round | 09/04/2024 | Maidenhead United | - | Hartlepool United | 3:1 | ||||
| 45. Round | 13/04/2024 | Hartlepool United | - | Dagenham & Redbridge | 1:1 | ||||
| 46. Round | 20/04/2024 | Dorking Wanderers | - | Hartlepool United | 3:4 |
England