| Squad | Appearances | ||
| sorting |
| Defender | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| John Leach |
|
England | 12/05/1866 | ||
| Midfielder | ||||||
| Robert Fish |
|
England | 26/05/1871 | ||
| Jimmy Forrest |
|
England | 24/06/1864 | ||
| James Haddow |
|
Scotland | 1872 | ||
| Michael McAvoy |
|
Scotland | 18/12/1870 | ||
| Forward | ||||||
| William Townley |
|
England | 14/02/1866 | ||
| Harry Tyrer |
|
England | 26/07/1868 | ||
