| Player | Country | Position | born | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | ||||
| Rupert Anderson |
|
England | Goalkeeper | 29/04/1859 |
| B | ||||
| Alexander Bonsor |
|
England | Forward | 07/10/1851 |
| Lindsay Bury |
|
England | Defender | 09/07/1857 |
| C | ||||
| John Chevallier |
|
England | Forward | 02/02/1857 |
| Edward Christian |
|
England | Defender | 14/09/1858 |
| D | ||||
| Arthur Dunn |
|
England | Forward | 12/08/1860 |
| G | ||||
| Harry Goodhart |
|
England | Forward | 17/07/1858 |
| Robert Gosling |
|
England | Forward | 15/06/1868 |
| H | ||||
| John Hawtrey |
|
England | Goalkeeper | 20/07/1850 |
| K | ||||
| Arthur Kinnaird |
|
Scotland | Midfielder | 16/02/1847 |
| O | ||||
| Cuthbert Ottaway |
|
England | Forward | 19/07/1850 |
| W | ||||
| Hertbert Whitfeld |
|
England | Forward | 15/11/1858 |
