Championship   M. W D L goals
  at home 3 0 2 1 4 : 5
  Away 3 1 1 1 4 : 6
  6 1 3 2 8 : 11
FA Cup   M. W D L goals
  Away 1 0 0 1 1 : 2
  1 0 0 1 1 : 2
League Cup   M. W D L goals
  at home 2 1 1 0 1 : 0
  Away 3 0 0 3 3 : 9
  5 1 1 3 4 : 9
overall   M. W D L goals
  at home 5 1 3 1 5 : 5
  Away 7 1 1 5 8 : 17
  Neutral Place 0 0 0 0 0 : 0
  12 2 4 6 13 : 22
Championship
1953/1954 8. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 3:0
1953/1954 3. Round Rotherham United - Everton FC 1:2
1952/1953 8. Round Rotherham United - Everton FC 2:2
1952/1953 4. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 0:1
1951/1952 6. Round Rotherham United - Everton FC 1:1
1951/1952 2. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 3:3
FA Cup
2020/2021 3. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 2:1 (1:0, 1:1) aet
League Cup
2018/2019 2. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 3:1 (1:0)
1992/1993 2. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 3:0
1992/1993 2. Round Rotherham United - Everton FC 1:0
1987/1988 2. Round Rotherham United - Everton FC 0:0
1987/1988 2. Round Everton FC - Rotherham United 3:2

For games that were decided on penalties the score after 120 minutes will be included in the ranking