Championship   M. W D L goals
  at home 22 8 5 9 31 : 39
  Away 22 4 5 13 22 : 50
  44 12 10 22 53 : 89
FA Cup   M. W D L goals
  at home 1 1 0 0 1 : 0
  Away 4 0 1 3 3 : 8
  5 1 1 3 4 : 8
League One   M. W D L goals
  at home 4 2 2 0 6 : 2
  Away 4 1 1 2 4 : 4
  8 3 3 2 10 : 6
overall   M. W D L goals
  at home 27 11 7 9 38 : 41
  Away 30 5 7 18 29 : 62
  Neutral Place 0 0 0 0 0 : 0
  57 16 14 27 67 : 103
Championship
2009/2010 18. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 0:0 (0:0)
2009/2010 31. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:3 (1:0)
2008/2009 46. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:2 (1:1)
2008/2009 24. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 2:0 (1:0)
2007/2008 32. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:0 (1:0)
2007/2008 3. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 3:2 (2:0)
2006/2007 38. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:4 (2:2)
2006/2007 12. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 2:2 (1:2)
1991/1992 6. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:3
1991/1992 1. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:1
1990/1991 8. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:0
1990/1991 5. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:1
1989/1990 6. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:1
1989/1990 2. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:1
1988/1989 9. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:2
1988/1989 3. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 3:1
1987/1988 9. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 0:0
1987/1988 2. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 2:1
1986/1987 7. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:0
1986/1987 2. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:1
1955/1956 8. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:0
1955/1956 3. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:2
1952/1953 7. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 4:0
1952/1953 3. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 0:3
1949/1950 9. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 4:1
1949/1950 5. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:2
1948/1949 5. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:1
1948/1949 1. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 0:0
1947/1948 6. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 2:1
1947/1948 2. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:0
1946/1947 8. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:2
1946/1947 4. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:3
1937/1938 9. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:2
1937/1938 5. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 3:2
1936/1937 8. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:2
1936/1937 4. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:3
1935/1936 7. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:2
1935/1936 3. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 7:1
1934/1935 8. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:4
1934/1935 3. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:1
1931/1932 7. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 3:0
1931/1932 3. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 0:0
1930/1931 6. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 0:4
1930/1931 2. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 4:0
FA Cup
1993/1994 4. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:0 (1:0)
1993/1994 4. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:2 (0:1)
1952/1953 4. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:0
1919/1920 2. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 4:1
1907/1908 1. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:0
League One
2022/2023 36. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 3:0 (0:0)
2022/2023 1. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:0 (1:0)
2018/2019 44. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 0:3 (0:3)
2018/2019 11. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:1 (1:1)
2003/2004 40. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:0 (0:0)
2003/2004 10. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 2:0 (1:0)
2002/2003 34. Round Plymouth Argyle - Barnsley FC 1:1 (1:0)
2002/2003 8. Round Barnsley FC - Plymouth Argyle 1:1 (1:1)

For games that were decided on penalties the score after 120 minutes will be included in the ranking