| All-time Topscorers | » All-time best penalty takers | All-time scorers (own goals) |
| Europa League + Fairs Cup | » Europa League only |
| # | Player | Team(s) | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dennis Aogo |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 |
| Nabil Bentaleb * |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| Franco Di Santo |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| Klaus Fichtel |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| Johannes Geis * |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| Klaas-Jan Huntelaar |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| Levan Kobiashvili |
FC Schalke 04
|
1 | |
| * Active player | |||
