| MLS | 07/06/19 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 5:2 | ||||
| MLS | 18/08/19 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 1:4 | ||||
| MLS | 13/09/20 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 2:1 |  |
|||
| MLS | 27/09/20 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 4:0 | ||||
| MLS | 24/04/21 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 5:0 | ||||
| MLS | 19/09/21 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 1:2 | ||||
| Open Cup | 11/05/23 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 1:0 | ||||
| MLS | 01/06/23 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 1:3 | |
|||
| MLS | 23/03/24 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 1:0 | ||||
| 06/08/24 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 4:2 | |||||
| MLS | 03/10/24 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 3:2 | |
|||
| MLS | 28/10/24 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 1:0 | |
|||
| MLS | 02/11/24 | New York City FC | - | FC Cincinnati | 3:1 | |
|||
| MLS | 09/11/24 | FC Cincinnati | - | New York City FC | 5:6 pso |
USA